The Storytellers Guild
Movies • Books • Writing
Talking about Fan Fiction
October 20, 2023

So as both a fan of pop culture, and now a writer/contributor, something I have become fascinated with is fan fiction.

 

It's obviously something that has been on the internet since...well, really the internet's existence. People feel inspired by a piece of media, and can't help but create their own stories and narratives with those characters. Especially when some characters seem to never get the time they deserve (Disney I'm talking to you! My boy Boba Fett is hurting from what you did to him!!)

 

Now, I'd also like to make the caveat that I'm not going to be talking about smutty fanfiction. I think that is in a genre of its own and has its own moral problems. 

 

But, the real question is: should fanfiction be allowed? On the one hand, you are stealing the IP of a professional creator. Taking their world, characters, ideas, and using them how you please. Sometimes even making money off of them. 

 

When it comes to legality, totally not allowed. But morally, what's your thoughts? For example, apparently someone had an AI service write the end of the GOT tv show because the actual end was so bad. It blew up because fans were really enjoying it, but Geaorge R R Martin had it removed from the internet. 

 

I think at a certain point, fans should be able to make money from it. I don't think it should just be a permission thing, because part of the "fan economy" that keeps your wokr going are the pieces of art, teh fan fiction stories, and everything else published around that. 

 

What do y'all think?

community logo
Join the The Storytellers Guild Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
6
What else you may like…
Posts
Articles
June 08, 2025
June 02, 2025

I started something, and im hoping to get your support, I will be doing stream of consciousness videos, and hope you find them intriguing 😊

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (Movie Review)

The Return of the King is a stunning conclusion to the trilogy, and the extended edition adds so much more depth to the story. An epic adventure of good against evil, a story of the power of friendship and individual courage, and the heroic quest to pave the way for the emergence of mankind.

The soundtrack, background, narrating and lore is exceptional.

Frodo, of course, wouldn’t have made it all the way to Mount Doom without Sam—he’s truly the backbone of the duo, always there to pick up the pieces when Frodo is at his lowest. I absolutely hate Denethor—he’s such a frustrating character, and Faramir’s tragic arc makes me feel so bad for him, especially during the battle of Osgiliath where they just get slaughtered.

That one line at the end, “You bow to no one”, was such a powerful moment in the film. I definitely got a little emotional in that scene. The Return of the King (Extended Edition) is a masterpiece that ...

post photo preview
post photo preview
Fan Film Lawsuites?
Fantasy News

As you know, Warner Brothers announced that it will be making a film called The Hunt for Gollum, directed by Andy Serkis and produced by Peter Jackson.

But…why does that title sound familiar? I was talking with a few friends about it when the story broke and someone mentioned that there was a fan film of the same name on YouTube. 

 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly: More Fantasy and Sci-fi Show
Fantasy News

 

So this week has been a wild one for fans of sci-fi and fantasy. Three trailers. Three shows. And three vastly different responses. If you don’t know what I’m talking about, the trailer for Rings of Power S2, House of the Dragon S2, and a new spin-off series Dune: Prophecy, all dropped this week. Which offers a unique (and probably intentional) opportunity to compare the three pieces, and their subsequent shows.

 

 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
They're Making a Gollum Movie?!!
Fantasy News

So…this is not just a headline. A few days ago, Warner Brothers announced a new slate of Lord of the Rings Movies, the first of which will be The Hunt for Gollum (an animated series which predates the LOTR timeline by 200 years will also be made called The War for the Rohirrim

 

Yes. I’m as confused as the rest of you. Does this mean more garbage like Rings of Power? Maybe…though not from the same source. It would be too long and, frankly, unnecessary to describe the strange division of copyright between Amazon and Warner Bros. Suffice it to say, Warner Bros. owns the rights to the main timelines about the actual characters. Amazon owns the rights to a prologue. 

 

Now, I’m as annoyed as the rest of you. They are making more Harry Potter, more Lord of the Rings, a freaking Mufasa movie?! What happened to original Hollywood stories?

 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals